|
Edvard Munch: Behind the Scream - Critical
acclaim
Tom Rosenthal The Independent On Sunday
'We are all now used to reading literary biographies which painstakingly
set out to prove that a writer's life was identical with his oeuvre
and that the books were wholly autobiographical. So it's an interesting
experience
to see this well-worn literary technique applied to Edvard Munch, the
one truly great painter produced by Norway and indeed by the four Scandinavian
countries. Sue Prideaux is well equipped for the task: part Norwegian,
fluent in the language, with a great-uncle, Thomas Olsen, who was one
of Munch's most loyal patrons. She grew up with his art if not with
his life.
This first full biography written in English shows, with painful clarity,
that his art is compulsively autobiographical. Every time Prideaux produces
a nugget of information so bizarre that it seems not only over the top
but thoroughly ben trovato there is a note giving the source in the vast
Munch archives in Oslo, since he was also an exhaustive verbal recorder
of his life.
Rarely in the canon of Western art has there been so much anxiety, fear
and deep psychological pain in one artist. That he lived to be 80 and
spent only one period in an asylum is a tribute not only to Munch's physical
stamina but to his iron will and his innate, robust psychological strength.
Munch was born in 1863, so sickly that he was immediately baptised in
case he did not survive. His mother, 23 years younger than his father,
produced five children but died, aged 30, of the TB rife in both 19th-century
Norway and her family. The father, Christian, was nearly 50 when Edvard
was born, He had graduated from serving on coffin ships to being an army
doctor, despite being unable to stand the sight of blood. He was also
a deeply Pietist Christian zealot and strict disciplinarian who, when
beating his children for minor infractions, would invoke the image of
their blessed mother who saw them from heaven and grieved over their
misbehaviour. Christian used to read Dostoevsky and Poe to his small
children, and was a hopeless economic provider, moving endlessly from
one insalubrious flat to another and sending the children out to beg
money from their richer relatives. His maternal grandfather had died
insane, with spinal TB and Edvard feared for most of his life that he
would die of the syphilis that was equally rife and also a precursor
of insanity.
The trauma of the loss of his mother was compounded a year or so later
by that of his beloved sister Sophie, the posthumous model for one of
his greatest paintings, The Sick Child. All his life, he kept the chair
in which she died. His brother died at 30 and his sister Laura had to
be institutionalised with schizophrenia. Only one of his siblings survived
him, his sister Inger, whom, with his maternal aunt Karen, he supported
once he could make a living as a painter, with whom he corresponded constantly
and lovingly, but whom he could not bring himself to visit.
His education was rudimentary as he entered the best schools but was
expelled, not for moral turpitude, but because, being constantly ill,
his attendance was so bad he couldn't keep up. Yet his artistic gifts,
largely untaught, manifested themselves at seven and, at 13, he was accepted
at the Art Association, an artists' club where he learnt by copying the
works on display. Aged 16, he entered the Technical School because he
was good at maths and physics but again left because of illness. It was
only then that he decided to become an artist and already he hated the
then obligatory varnishing of every oil surface. "No more brown
sauce" were his words, echoing Goethe who used the same phrase in
his exploration of colour theory in 1810.
Shortly after this, round about the time Ibsen published Ghosts in 1881,
Munch entered the Bohemian circle of Kristiania (it did not become Oslo
until 1925). His principal mentors were the rumbustious and highly successful
painter Christian Krohg and the sinister, syphilitic Hans Jaeger, a stenographer
in the Norwegian Parliament. The acknowledged leader of the group, Jaeger
was an intellectual wild man, a nihilist who believed that he should
drive both his enemies and his disciples to suicide. His effect on Munch
happily did not involve suicide but Munch admitted in later life that
Jaeger's influence on him had been profound.
Munch lost his virginity to a well-connected army wife who made him
feel guilty as an adulterer and deeply jealous as she simultaneously
carried on with other men. Add to this the alcohol he consumed in heroic
quantities, the time he spent in brothels and the temptations of a Bohemian
crowd, and it's a miracle that this handsome but frequently sickly youth
survived at all, let alone lived to be 80.
Once he began to show his pictures, he always had a tiny group of supporters
who enabled him to survive psychologically more or less intact even though
he was always on the breadline. He sold an early work to the nascent
Norwegian National Gallery and got two state scholarships, one of which
stipulated that he had to learn to draw, which took him to Paris where
he studied the work of others but took few lessons.
Paris was followed by Berlin and the heady days of The Black Piglet
tavern with Strindberg and the beautiful femme fatale Dagny Juel. She
ditched both Munch and Strindberg to marry the charismatic Polish writer
Stanislaw Przybyszewski and was later murdered by a fraudulent Polish
lover. Munch's relationship with Strindberg was extraordinary. There
was intense mutual admiration but, in the end, paranoia induced fear
and suspicion on both sides which caused a rift. Both loved and feared
women. Strindberg actually married three of them but as Munch described
it: "I have always put my art before everything else. Often I felt
that Woman would stand in the way of my art. I decided at an early age
never to marry."
The Swede put the Norwegian into his books and plays in a thoroughly
unflattering light. When Munch lithographed him he labelled him Stindberg,
which means, in Norwegian, "mountain of hot air". Yet each
acknowledged his debt to the other and, given Munch's fear of "Vampire
women", there are several paintings in the great Frieze of Life
sequence which bear traces of Strindberg's influence as well as the autobiographical
elements of the recognisable women in Munch's life. As with Strindberg,
and all devoted paranoiacs, some of those who Munch believed had harmed
him had indeed done so, notably Tulla Larsen who had made the first advances
and who had, in stalker fashion, done everything possible to turn her
lover into her husband. This included threats of breach of promise, fake
suicide attempts and the catastrophic pistol episode - no one knows who
fired the shot - when the bullet lodged in the middle finger of Munch's
left hand. This left the hand that held his palette and his etching plates
permanently maimed, necessitating a glove for the rest of his life. (This
event inspired the magnificent Death of Marat painting.) No wonder he
declared that women had nutcracker muscles in their thighs and reduced
men to soup.
Munch was, at least until he checked himself into Doctor Jacobsen's
psychological clinic in Copenhagen in 1908, a compulsive frequenter of
brothels; he once spent an entire Christmas in one. It is a wonder that
he escaped the syphilis he feared, but Jacobsen diagnosed only alcoholism
as the primary cause of Munch's temporary insanity. Munch ruefully accepted
that he would have, in future, to confine himself to "tobacco-free
cigars, alcohol-free drinks and poison-free women". But, according
to Prideaux, he resisted Jacobsen's psychological probings and effected
his own mental cure at the clinic. His stay coincided with a hugely successful
show in Kristiania with 60,000 Kroner worth of sales. Munch paid for
a celebratory dinner for his friends at his favourite Norwegian watering
hole, the Grand Hotel, and kept an open telephone line to his Copenhagen
bedside so that he could join in the fun.
Munch had great success in Germany via various avant garde Jewish dealers
and enlightened rich patrons, but the post-First World War hyper-inflation
ruined them and, despite his early enthusiasm, Goebbels, who wrote him
an egregious fan letter on his 70th birthday - in 1933, the year the
Nazis came to power - dropped him as soon as the Nazi policy of pillorying
Entartete Kunst (Decadent Art) came in. The 80 or so Munchs in German
collections were held to official ridicule and then sold on the international
market, including Norway, to raise hard currency for National Socialism.
Despite that, the Quisling-led government in occupied Norway during
the Second World War tried to make Munch the figurehead of its Honorary
Board of Norwegian Artists. Munch refused and the Board was dropped.
The government commandeered one of his major houses, failed to get to
his hoard of paintings but, on his death, as the author puts it, "hijacked" his
corpse and burial so that instead of a simple interment in the family
plot, he was given a state funeral with gigantic Nazi insignia and flags.
The years of his success and wealth were lived frugally in a large house
at Ekely, whose locked second floor contained his bequest to Norway of
thousands of works of art. He had a succession of "poison-free women",
a series of beautiful models whom he painted with undiminished erotic
joy and sexual tension.
Munch said that his paintings were his children, even though he gave
many of them a somewhat Spartan upbringing, deliberately leaving them
not only unvarnished but exposed to the elements in his vast outdoor
studio or hung on walls, unframed and with nails through them. His vast
heritage of great paintings and lithographs exists as both testament
and record of his life. He once wrote: "Just as Leonardo studied
the recesses of the human body and dissected cadavers, I try from self-scrutiny
to dissect what is universal in the soul."
Prideaux has written a life which goes a long way towards upholding
his aim and anyone who wants to know how and why he painted as he did
should read this book.
We are all now used to reading literary biographies which painstakingly
set out to prove that a writer's life was identical with his oeuvre and
that the books were wholly autobiographical. So it's an interesting experience
to see this well-worn literary technique applied to Edvard Munch, the
one truly great painter produced by Norway and indeed by the four Scandinavian
countries. Sue Prideaux is well equipped for the task: part Norwegian,
fluent in the language, with a great-uncle, Thomas Olsen, who was one
of Munch's most loyal patrons. She grew up with his art if not with his
life.
This first full biography written in English shows, with painful clarity,
that his art is compulsively autobiographical. Every time Prideaux produces
a nugget of information so bizarre that it seems not only over the top
but thoroughly ben trovato there is a note giving the source in the vast
Munch archives in Oslo, since he was also an exhaustive verbal recorder
of his life.
Rarely in the canon of Western art has there been so much anxiety, fear
and deep psychological pain in one artist. That he lived to be 80 and
spent only one period in an asylum is a tribute not only to Munch's physical
stamina but to his iron will and his innate, robust psychological strength.
Munch was born in 1863, so sickly that he was immediately baptised in
case he did not survive. His mother, 23 years younger than his father,
produced five children but died, aged 30, of the TB rife in both 19th-century
Norway and her family. The father, Christian, was nearly 50 when Edvard
was born, He had graduated from serving on coffin ships to being an army
doctor, despite being unable to stand the sight of blood. He was also
a deeply Pietist Christian zealot and strict disciplinarian who, when
beating his children for minor infractions, would invoke the image of
their blessed mother who saw them from heaven and grieved over their
misbehaviour. Christian used to read Dostoevsky and Poe to his small
children, and was a hopeless economic provider, moving endlessly from
one insalubrious flat to another and sending the children out to beg
money from their richer relatives. His maternal grandfather had died
insane, with spinal TB and Edvard feared for most of his life that he
would die of the syphilis that was equally rife and also a precursor
of insanity.
The trauma of the loss of his mother was compounded a year or so later
by that of his beloved sister Sophie, the posthumous model for one of
his greatest paintings, The Sick Child. All his life, he kept the chair
in which she died. His brother died at 30 and his sister Laura had to
be institutionalised with schizophrenia. Only one of his siblings survived
him, his sister Inger, whom, with his maternal aunt Karen, he supported
once he could make a living as a painter, with whom he corresponded constantly
and lovingly, but whom he could not bring himself to visit.
His education was rudimentary as he entered the best schools but was
expelled, not for moral turpitude, but because, being constantly ill,
his attendance was so bad he couldn't keep up. Yet his artistic gifts,
largely untaught, manifested themselves at seven and, at 13, he was accepted
at the Art Association, an artists' club where he learnt by copying the
works on display. Aged 16, he entered the Technical School because he
was good at maths and physics but again left because of illness. It was
only then that he decided to become an artist and already he hated the
then obligatory varnishing of every oil surface. "No more brown
sauce" were his words, echoing Goethe who used the same phrase in
his exploration of colour theory in 1810.
Shortly after this, round about the time Ibsen published Ghosts in 1881,
Munch entered the Bohemian circle of Kristiania (it did not become Oslo
until 1925). His principal mentors were the rumbustious and highly successful
painter Christian Krohg and the sinister, syphilitic Hans Jaeger, a stenographer
in the Norwegian Parliament. The acknowledged leader of the group, Jaeger
was an intellectual wild man, a nihilist who believed that he should
drive both his enemies and his disciples to suicide. His effect on Munch
happily did not involve suicide but Munch admitted in later life that
Jaeger's influence on him had been profound.
Munch lost his virginity to a well-connected army wife who made him
feel guilty as an adulterer and deeply jealous as she simultaneously
carried on with other men. Add to this the alcohol he consumed in heroic
quantities, the time he spent in brothels and the temptations of a Bohemian
crowd, and it's a miracle that this handsome but frequently sickly youth
survived at all, let alone lived to be 80.
Once he began to show his pictures, he always had a tiny group of supporters
who enabled him to survive psychologically more or less intact even though
he was always on the breadline. He sold an early work to the nascent
Norwegian National Gallery and got two state scholarships, one of which
stipulated that he had to learn to draw, which took him to Paris where
he studied the work of others but took few lessons.
Paris was followed by Berlin and the heady days of The Black Piglet tavern
with Strindberg and the beautiful femme fatale Dagny Juel. She ditched both
Munch and Strindberg to marry the charismatic Polish writer Stanislaw Przybyszewski
and was later murdered by a fraudulent Polish lover. Munch's relationship with
Strindberg was extraordinary. There was intense mutual admiration but, in the
end, paranoia induced fear and suspicion on both sides which caused a rift.
Both loved and feared women. Strindberg actually married three of them but
as Munch described it: "I have always put my art before everything else.
Often I felt that Woman would stand in the way of my art. I decided at an early
age never to marry."
The Swede put the Norwegian into his books and plays in a thoroughly
unflattering light. When Munch lithographed him he labelled him Stindberg,
which means, in Norwegian, "mountain of hot air". Yet each
acknowledged his debt to the other and, given Munch's fear of "Vampire
women", there are several paintings in the great Frieze of Life
sequence which bear traces of Strindberg's influence as well as the autobiographical
elements of the recognisable women in Munch's life. As with Strindberg,
and all devoted paranoiacs, some of those who Munch believed had harmed
him had indeed done so, notably Tulla Larsen who had made the first advances
and who had, in stalker fashion, done everything possible to turn her
lover into her husband. This included threats of breach of promise, fake
suicide attempts and the catastrophic pistol episode - no one knows who
fired the shot - when the bullet lodged in the middle finger of Munch's
left hand. This left the hand that held his palette and his etching plates
permanently maimed, necessitating a glove for the rest of his life. (This
event inspired the magnificent Death of Marat painting.) No wonder he
declared that women had nutcracker muscles in their thighs and reduced
men to soup.
Munch was, at least until he checked himself into Doctor Jacobsen's
psychological clinic in Copenhagen in 1908, a compulsive frequenter of
brothels; he once spent an entire Christmas in one. It is a wonder that
he escaped the syphilis he feared, but Jacobsen diagnosed only alcoholism
as the primary cause of Munch's temporary insanity. Munch ruefully accepted
that he would have, in future, to confine himself to "tobacco-free
cigars, alcohol-free drinks and poison-free women". But, according
to Prideaux, he resisted Jacobsen's psychological probings and effected
his own mental cure at the clinic. His stay coincided with a hugely successful
show in Kristiania with 60,000 Kroner worth of sales. Munch paid for
a celebratory dinner for his friends at his favourite Norwegian watering
hole, the Grand Hotel, and kept an open telephone line to his Copenhagen
bedside so that he could join in the fun.
Munch had great success in Germany via various avant garde Jewish dealers
and enlightened rich patrons, but the post-First World War hyper-inflation
ruined them and, despite his early enthusiasm, Goebbels, who wrote him
an egregious fan letter on his 70th birthday - in 1933, the year the
Nazis came to power - dropped him as soon as the Nazi policy of pillorying
Entartete Kunst (Decadent Art) came in. The 80 or so Munchs in German
collections were held to official ridicule and then sold on the international
market, including Norway, to raise hard currency for National Socialism.
Despite that, the Quisling-led government in occupied Norway during
the Second World War tried to make Munch the figurehead of its Honorary
Board of Norwegian Artists. Munch refused and the Board was dropped.
The government commandeered one of his major houses, failed to get to
his hoard of paintings but, on his death, as the author puts it, "hijacked" his
corpse and burial so that instead of a simple interment in the family
plot, he was given a state funeral with gigantic Nazi insignia and flags.
The years of his success and wealth were lived frugally in a large house
at Ekely, whose locked second floor contained his bequest to Norway of
thousands of works of art. He had a succession of "poison-free women",
a series of beautiful models whom he painted with undiminished erotic
joy and sexual tension.
Munch said that his paintings were his children, even though he gave
many of them a somewhat Spartan upbringing, deliberately leaving them
not only unvarnished but exposed to the elements in his vast outdoor
studio or hung on walls, unframed and with nails through them. His vast
heritage of great paintings and lithographs exists as both testament
and record of his life. He once wrote: "Just as Leonardo studied
the recesses of the human body and dissected cadavers, I try from self-scrutiny
to dissect what is universal in the soul."
Prideaux has written a life which goes a long way towards upholding
his aim and anyone who wants to know how and why he painted as he did
should read this book.'
Tom Rosenthal, The Independent On Sunday
18 September 2005 |
|
|
|